front sway bar link, struts - diagnosis, parts+labor
#1
front sway bar link, struts - diagnosis, parts+labor
Three times, three days in a row on my 80k 03 Bonneville I heard an alarming metallic POP when turning right up onto my driveway bump. The noise seemed to be on the right. All my steering and front suspension seems to work ok despite this driveway bump noise. Recently I've had a very good experience at Meineke (only half a mile away) for AC problems, so I went there. But the AC was strictly labor, no parts and no up-selling of parts.
So they looked, then showed me a broken "sway bar link" on the driver'* side. But then the guy said they discovered that both the cars front struts have "binding upper bearing plates". He said it'* usually about the same cost to install entire strut assemblies if available (low labor) as to put in new bearing plates (high labor). He said this is more dangerous than the sway bar link. He'd call me when he got a solid estimate worked up.
They've now quoted me $93 inclusive to fix the broken "sway bar link". As a no-nothing it seems ok. But the quote is another $706 to install 2 new strut assemblies. Meanwhile I'd priced strut assemblies at RockAuto, Amazon, and AutoZone. Rock has the Unity brand for $85 shipped each, Amazon has Monroe for around $75 shipped each, Zone a bit more. So I asked the guy how much for the strut labor. "Around $200", which means $250+ part cost for each strut. I questioned him about providing my own struts, nope, no can do, national policy, warranty issues.
I ask here to have some pro-types weigh in on what to do. I certainly don't want to pay about $800 when everything feels fine, seems to function fine, but I need to make the car safe.
So they looked, then showed me a broken "sway bar link" on the driver'* side. But then the guy said they discovered that both the cars front struts have "binding upper bearing plates". He said it'* usually about the same cost to install entire strut assemblies if available (low labor) as to put in new bearing plates (high labor). He said this is more dangerous than the sway bar link. He'd call me when he got a solid estimate worked up.
They've now quoted me $93 inclusive to fix the broken "sway bar link". As a no-nothing it seems ok. But the quote is another $706 to install 2 new strut assemblies. Meanwhile I'd priced strut assemblies at RockAuto, Amazon, and AutoZone. Rock has the Unity brand for $85 shipped each, Amazon has Monroe for around $75 shipped each, Zone a bit more. So I asked the guy how much for the strut labor. "Around $200", which means $250+ part cost for each strut. I questioned him about providing my own struts, nope, no can do, national policy, warranty issues.
I ask here to have some pro-types weigh in on what to do. I certainly don't want to pay about $800 when everything feels fine, seems to function fine, but I need to make the car safe.
Last edited by 03SLE-SteelBlue; 10-07-2014 at 11:33 AM.
#2
Senior Member
True Car Nut
Joined: Sep 2006
Posts: 4,816
Likes: 245
From: Windsor, Ontario / Detroit, Michigan
Fix the sway bar links and see if the problem goes away. When I did mine I paid $15 for the parts and it took 15 minutes to change them. Very easy to do.
#3
dont take anything to the national chains, they treat people like they work on commission. find a good locally owned shop to go to if you dont feel comfortable. sway bar end links is a nothing deal which is why they made up the needs every part of the struts nonsense
The following users liked this post:
03SLE-SteelBlue (10-07-2014)
#4
OK guys, I'll just fix the sway bar link(*) at a local shop and see if they find any other problems. I won't be surprised if they find a struts problem, though, as for many months there'* been a soft popping sound as I turn the wheel sharply at say 5mph in parking lots. It'* more pronounced in hot weather. Not at all the same loud sharp single pop in the driveway I've got now. My last car had that soft popping sounds and this other local shop thought it was strut bushings. I traded that car without doing anything.
By the time the local can take it in I bet you can advise me on whether to mention those soft popping sounds.
By the time the local can take it in I bet you can advise me on whether to mention those soft popping sounds.
#6
So yesterday I called the only (still open for business) local indie garage I've ever actually used to see what they'd say. I only told them about the one broken sway bar link. They can "look at it" next week, then order parts(*), then have me return. So I made an appointment with them. Meanwhile, I just found out Meineke'* c$93 estimate for the link was actually installing a 2-pack, both sides makes sense, and they can do it tomorrow after the parts come in. So I made that appointment. I doubt there would be a lot of difference from 93 by going to the indie, meanwhile having several more days of nervous max 35mph driving. I may keep the indie appt but ask them instead to look at the struts.
#7
P.*. looking at Goog search results for GM broken sway bar links it seems a lot of the late 90s-early 00s GMs and OEMs had flimsy hollow easy-break links and the aftermarkets were often solid. I wonder if I should be looking for a specific brand.
#8
they almost always come in two because they get rusty then break and the other one is not that far behind. when they went on my bonnie i got two of the good napa ones for less than 20 bucks. driving the car without them isnt a big deal.
#9
for keeping up on this, and the advice. I figured 2 is sensible, your reason. Meineke uses Moog for this. I also wondered why not a whole new sway bar since it too may be ready to go. I'm also glad to hear no big deal.